The Proposal

3 out of 5 stars

The Proposal

 

Directed by: Anne Fletcher

Starring: Sandra Bullock

Genre: Comedy/ Romance

Run Time: 108 min.

Release Date: July 2009

On The Web: Official Site

Teaser: Movie Trailer

Reviewed by Byron Merritt

Although entertaining to a point, there are too many similarities to other comedies to make THE PROPOSAL anything but ordinary.

Most notably I found the plot to be very similar to another, older Sandra Bullock movie, WHILE YOU WERE SLEEPING. But this time we have an accomplice in the deceit and he’s not in a coma. Seriously. Think about it...

A woman who is in need of something (in this case a need not to be deported) comes up with a plan to achieve that goal (whether by accident – While You Were Sleeping – or not – The Proposal). Girl falls for the wrong guy. Guy falls for wrong girl. Family gets fooled. Girl confesses and thinks she’s lost everything. Guy chases down girl with the approval of the family. Everyone lives happily ever after. Ta-da!

The entertainment value in the film comes from the first half of the movie in which we have plenty of comedic zingers flying about, including quite a few from Grandma Annie (Betty White) while trying to dress Margaret (Sandra Bullock, THE LAKE HOUSE) in a wedding dress and losing – then finding – her breasts.

The cast is good in their respective roles, including main love interest Ryan Reynolds (SMOKIN’ ACES) playing Andrew Paxton, a sort of rich boy playing poor boy in order to tick-off his father, Joe, played by Craig T. Nelson (THE FAMILY STONE). Nelson just seems to be going through the motions during the entire film and never really gains any traction. As does Mary Steenburgen (THE DEAD GIRL) who plays Reynold’s mother.

The other problem with the casting is that we just don’t get that romantic air between Bullock and Reynolds’ characters. She is obviously much older than him (can you say "cougar?"), which isn’t always a problem but, again, there just didn’t seem much attraction going on. They fight, argue and never really resolve anything before miraculously falling in love ...because of one kiss?

Let’s get real...

Even with these flaws, the comedic timing is excellent and the visual backdrops of Boston and the (supposed) Alaskan countryside can take one’s breath away. Also, the Paxton family house is stunning to see.

Looking for something original? Not here. Want a fantastic romance story? Not here either. Looking for something entertaining, funny, and visual appealing? Give this one a try.

 

(back to top)

 

 

 

 

Image from The Proposal

Margaret (Sandra Bullock) informs her boss that she and her assistant, Andrew (Ryan Reynolds), are getting married

 

 

 

 

DVD cost: $35.03

Purchase: Tower.com (Blu-Ray)

Film Review Stew Favorite? No.

Stew Poo-Poo? No.

Newsworthy: Julia Roberts was the first choice to play Margaret, but reportedly refused to take a pay cut, so Sandra Bullock took over the role.

Movie Quote: "Actually I picked up on all her little hints. This woman is about as subtle as a gun."

 

Other Actors/Actresses from The Proposal

Dale PlaceMary Linda RapelyeMichael Mosley

 

 

Images from The Proposal

Margaret (Bullock) tries to protect the Paxton family dog from eagles up in Alaska

Andrew (Reynolds) forces Margaret (Bullock) to propose to him properly

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Got comments or questions about The Film Review Stew?Email us.