For Your Consideration

2 out of 5 stars

For Your Consideration

 

Directed by: Christopher Guest

Starring: Catherine O'Hara

Genre: Comedy

Run Time: 86 min.

Release Date: November 2006

On The Web: Official Site

Teaser: Movie Trailer

Reviewed by Byron Merritt

Christopher Guest has given us cinematic magic before with such things as A MIGHTY WIND and BEST IN SHOW. Both had heart, comedy, and understated grace. But here with FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION, that previously successful recipe gets watered down so much that it killed the entire story. There were adequate moments — thanks purely to Catherine O’Hara — but they were seldom and lost amidst the scriptless format that director Guest so loves to play with.

Guest reunites with his troupe of actors and tries his darnedest to give us some thought-provoking laughs. This time the story is about actors. Specifically, it’s a group of actors who are on their downward slope of their acting careers (or are on a slope that never existed). Currently these folks are making a B-movie-ish title called ‘Home For Purim.’ Catherine O’Hara, (MONSTER HOUSE) stars as Marilyn Hack (catch the last name there?), a B or C — or however far down the alphabet you want to go — list actress who’s name suddenly gets noticed in a Hollywood blurb on the web. The site mentions the word “Oscar” and Marilyn is beside herself with concern. Could she be listed as a nominee? Oscar buzz grips the studio where ‘Home For Purim’ is being filmed. A possible second nomination is also mentioned for another star of ‘Home For Purim’. The cast is electrified and divided. Feelings get bruised as some feel they should have gotten a mention or are jealous of the potential nominees.

Acting agents get involved, producers fall over themselves to appease the distribution company (eventually changing the title to ‘Home For Thanksgiving’ because ‘Home For Purim’ sounds too Jewish), and the cast prepares for the Oscar nomination list one fateful early morning.

Needless to say, the buzz quickly peters out once the Oscar list is read and the two would-be nominees aren’t on it (but someone else is!)

Christopher Guest tries admirably to show how hype doesn’t translate to success in Hollywood, and how wrapped up and self-indulgent everyone can become (Catherine O’Hara’s plastic surgery metamorphosis is actually quite funny).

But the short screen time (86 minutes) rules out any possibility of getting to know these characters, which is pretty disastrous considering this is a character study film.

Stick with Guest’s earlier flicks and you’ll be much happier with him as a whole.

 

(back to top)

 

 

 

 

Image from For Your Consideration

Catherine O'Hara as Marilyn Hack discusses the possibility of an Oscar mention with John Michael Higgins (Corey Taft)

 

 

 

 

DVD cost: $24.99

Purchase: BestPrices.com

Film Review Stew Favorite? No.

Stew Poo-Poo? No..

Newsworthy: Catherine O'Hara got several award nods for her portrayal of Marilyn Hack, including a win at The National Board of Review for Best Supporting Actress and a win from The Independent Spirit Awards for Best Female Lead.

Movie Quote: "Just tone-down the Jewish-ness ...so that everyone can enjoy it."

 

Other Actors/Actresses from For Your Consideration

Ed Begley Jr.Jennifer CoolidgeJohn Michael Higgins

 

 

Images from For Your Consideration

The cast of 'Home For Purim' or is it 'Home For Thanksgiving'?

Harry Shearer (Victor, left) discusses acting opportunities with his agent played by Eugene Levy

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Got comments or questions about The Film Review Stew? Email us.