Dear Frankie

4 out of 5 stars

Dear Frankie

 

Directed by: Shona Auerback

Starring: Emily Mortimer

Genre: Drama

Run Time: 105 min.

Release Date: March 2005

On The Web: Official Site

Teaser: Movie Trailer

Reviewed by Byron Merritt

DEAR FRANKIE is a heartwarming tale about the deception a parent is willing to portray in order to protect a child. Shot in Glasgow, Scotland by Director Shona Auerbach with her husband operating as a cameraman, this movie’s strong characters will tug at heartstrings in a very positive way.

The story is that of Frankie (Jack McElhone) and his mother Lizzie (Emily Mortimer, MATCH POINT). Recently relocating to yet another new city, Frankie immediately begins writing letters to his father again as soon as he’s able. He’s been doing this for years and years, never having met his father and only knowing — via his mum — that his dad is at sea on a boat named the Accra. Frankie’s dad writes back often and Frankie keeps track of his father’s movements around the world via a large map posted above his bed. In addition to lacking an active father, Frankie also can’t hear, being deaf (supposedly) since birth. This is an additional challenge for him since he has to re-orient people to his handicap every time they move to a new town. Classmates, store owners, librarians, all of them have varying degrees of pity, anxiety, and teasing that easily bounce off of Frankie’s prominent mental armor. He’s a smart kid, and a “champion lip reader.”

But Frankie’s world is about to change once he learns that his father’s ship is scheduled to port at the local docks of their new hometown! Frankie is beside himself with joy, but his mother is strangely downcast. And for good reason. Frankie’s father is not on a ship at sea and never has been. Lizzie (his mum) has been writing those letters back to Frankie, pretending to be his seafaring father. She had no idea that a ship called the Accra even existed, and now she must deal with its impending arrival and the unveiling of her lies to her son.

Not willing to give-in that easily, Lizzie concocts a plan to have a “Stranger” pose as Frankie’s father. She meets up with this dark but handsome man that we come to know only as The Stranger (Gerard Butler, BEOWULF & GRENDEL) and promises him an amount of money if he’ll pose, for a day, as her son’s father. The Stranger agrees, thus setting up circumstances that will lead to a love that Frankie, Lizzie, or even The Stranger thought impossible.

Young Jack McElhone gives a silent yet powerful performance as Frankie, the boy who knows more than he ever lets on. His sweet role is a marvel. Emily Mortimer gives a good performance as Lizzie, Frankie’s mum, but is anchored even stronger in her character thanks to the handsome Gerard Butler. Butler’s distant but involved portrayal of The Stranger is pulled off exceptionally well, especially since, as the audience, we know nothing about him before, during, or after his visit with Frankie and Lizzie. We suspect several things, though (he may have had an absent father, too, or had a bad relationship that ended in divorce like Lizzie’s ...although we’re never given any information as such).

The only downer is the side-story relating to Frankie’s “real” father who is dying of cancer. Perhaps it would have been best to keep any firm father-figure (be it paternal or otherwise) distant from Frankie’s life, or fleeting (as in The Stranger). The hospital scenes with Frankie’s biological father felt forced and unnecessary.

Otherwise, this is a gem of a film that’ll make you smile, shed a few tears, and be grateful there are Strangers among us who can fill the ample shoes of fathers.

 

(back to top)

 

 

 

 

Image from Dear Frankie

Frankie and 'The Stranger' act as father and son

 

 

 

 

DVD cost: $23.99

Purchase: BestPrices.com

Film Review Stew Favorite? No.

Stew Poo-Poo? No.

Newsworthy: The song that plays while Lizzie (Emily Mortimer) is sitting on a bench crying after a fruitless attempt to find a "daddy" for Frankie, is written by one of the most famous contemporary Estonian composer - Arvo Paaumlrt.
 

Movie Quote: "You have to face this sometime. Tell Frankie the truth."

 

Other Actors/Actresses from Dear Frankie

Mary RiggansSean BrownSharon Small

 

 

Images from Dear Frankie

Lizzie and 'The Stranger' have a lovely dance

Lizze, Frankie and 'The Stranger' look silently out to sea, each thinking the same thing

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Got comments or questions about The Film Review Stew?Email us.